Casar66 Posted July 24 Report Posted July 24 Yes, I have found it too. But what would happen if I try copper leads? Or is anyone around here who has already tried this? Quote
RobH Posted July 24 Report Posted July 24 (edited) Using plain copper leads will increase high-frequency ignition noise since the voltage rise-time is faster. That noise could possibly affect the operation of the ignition module, though the effect on any particular installation can really only be determined by trying it out. It could be that in some cases using resistor spark-plugs with copper leads would give enough suppression. There is plenty of opinion on the web but nothing definitive. I have looked but can't find any proper technical documents discussing this; nor does there seem to be anything concrete on whether the noise can cause failure of the modules or just causes them to become confused. All we have is the above statement by the makers, which could just be erring on the safe side to forestall come-backs if it doesn't work. (Also they would like to sell you their own HT leads of course ! ) Edited July 24 by RobH Quote
Casar66 Posted July 24 Report Posted July 24 (edited) Well then it is a should I try or should I go and buy another kit thing. The Accuspark should be a perfect testimonial.... Edited July 24 by Casar66 Quote
Casar66 Posted July 24 Report Posted July 24 I decided to go for a new set of ignition leads instead testing with copper leads and accuspark or Pertronix. If the theory ist right that the restistance of the Bosch WR78 is too high, then a change of the spark plugs to non resistor ones should help. So I change the WR78 with the Champion N9YC expecting a smoother run especially at lower revs. The result: No difference. Quote
Jules TR6 Posted July 25 Author Report Posted July 25 (edited) 14 hours ago, Casar66 said: I decided to go for a new set of ignition leads instead testing with copper leads and accuspark or Pertronix. If the theory ist right that the restistance of the Bosch WR78 is too high, then a change of the spark plugs to non resistor ones should help. So I change the WR78 with the Champion N9YC expecting a smoother run especially at lower revs. The result: No difference. So you kept the original carbon HT leads and changed the plugs? That should be a good balance in terms of suppression. You also have a Flamethrower 0.6 ohm coil now? The electronic ignition module is an Ignitor 2? - which should be paired with an 0.6 ohm coil. You also mention Accuspark - is that the carbon HT leads? First I’d check that the timing is not too advanced. Then it’s check injectors. Possibly the carbon leads have a fracture, old carbon leads can develop problems. If you do replace the leads I would not recommend copper, not worth the risk with electronic ignition. The electronic ignition system had been working well previously, or the engine has never been running correctly with it installed? Edited July 25 by Jules TR6 Quote
Casar66 Posted July 25 Report Posted July 25 (edited) First off: if I'm derailing this thread, please let me know—that's not my intention The ignition had worked many years pretty well with cheap components, Accuspark leads and ignition, Lucas gold coil, WR78. Around 8 years ago problems arrived. Not big ones, only that the ignition was not that smooth. It’s noticeable as a slightly rough running when accelerating from low RPMs in a high gear. Change to Ignitor 2. Helped for a short time. Then new Carbon leads (cheap) from Bastuck and new Lucas Cap. Helped for a short time. Then the Bosch blue coil. Helped for 5 Years (but less than 3000mls). This thread here is what first got me interested in the topic of resistance in the ignition system ( I did not even know that a suppressed plug comes along with higher restistance) Except for the Ignitor 2, I’ve now ordered all the components new (previously, I had replaced some individual components I still had on hand, all without making any changes). The distributor contact plate is grounded. It’s not that the engine runs really badly. But it’s just not perfect. Timing and injectors are all good. I forgot to mention that I don't have a ballast resistor wire in the harness. Forgot to mention II: the new components haven't arrived yet. If those don't help either, I'll go back to a standard ignition switch. Or I'll invest in a new electronic ignition system. But it won't be a Pertronix anymore. And it won't be cheap stuff like Auccuspark or Powerspark either. 123 is out too—I want to keep my distributor and my tachometer. Edited July 25 by Casar66 Quote
Jules TR6 Posted July 25 Author Report Posted July 25 2 hours ago, Casar66 said: First off: if I'm derailing this thread, please let me know—that's not my intention The ignition had worked many years pretty well with cheap components, Accuspark leads and ignition, Lucas gold coil, WR78. Around 8 years ago problems arrived. Not big ones, only that the ignition was not that smooth. It’s noticeable as a slightly rough running when accelerating from low RPMs in a high gear. Change to Ignitor 2. Helped for a short time. Then new Carbon leads (cheap) from Bastuck and new Lucas Cap. Helped for a short time. Then the Bosch blue coil. Helped for 5 Years (but less than 3000mls). This thread here is what first got me interested in the topic of resistance in the ignition system ( I did not even know that a suppressed plug comes along with higher restistance) Except for the Ignitor 2, I’ve now ordered all the components new (previously, I had replaced some individual components I still had on hand, all without making any changes). The distributor contact plate is grounded. It’s not that the engine runs really badly. But it’s just not perfect. Timing and injectors are all good. I forgot to mention that I don't have a ballast resistor wire in the harness. Forgot to mention II: the new components haven't arrived yet. If those don't help either, I'll go back to a standard ignition switch. Or I'll invest in a new electronic ignition system. But it won't be a Pertronix anymore. And it won't be cheap stuff like Auccuspark or Powerspark either. 123 is out too—I want to keep my distributor and my tachometer. ...ok, from old black worn points that came with the car when I purchased it, along with very rough running, I went to Powerspark, a quick easy method to have a fresh start along with new plug. Performance felt flat even with quite advanced timing. Went back to points. All good. Then the electronic ignition bug hit again, I got a Pertronix Ignitor I (as I'd read it often works better with the TR6 then the MkII Ignitor) - this did give more easy starting, but produced hesitant coughing/clapping acceleration at low revs, and the odd pop at high rev... I tried different plugs and a range of timing. Also the engine sounded louder. I wasn't happy the engine wasn't happy. I went back to points, all good again, amazingly good. The points, condenser and rotor came from the Distributor Doctor (as did the 3ohm Flamethrower, and the Ignitor - which is now relegated to the spare part bin). I also looked into 123 but wanted to keep the dizzy with mechanical tacho, so as recommended by DD I got the Ignitor. For other reasons I've had a lot of communications with Martin at 'Fred Millturn Parts', a specialist in TR6 Injection, he said don't use electronic ignition the TR6 PI doesn't like it. He's right. If you do 'go back' to points ensure you use a 3ohm coil. My setup is a Flamethrower 3ohm (does seem to be the best coil I've used). Points, Condenser and Cap from the Distributor Doctor. Magnecor 7mm electrosports HT leads (black, no bright colours!). Bosch W7DTC plugs. I've tried many combinations, this is the best. Quote
stuart Posted July 25 Report Posted July 25 44 minutes ago, Jules TR6 said: ...ok, from old black worn points that came with the car when I purchased it, along with very rough running, I went to Powerspark, a quick easy method to have a fresh start along with new plug. Performance felt flat even with quite advanced timing. Went back to points. All good. Then the electronic ignition bug hit again, I got a Pertronix Ignitor I (as I'd read it often works better with the TR6 then the MkII Ignitor) - this did give more easy starting, but produced hesitant coughing/clapping acceleration at low revs, and the odd pop at high rev... I tried different plugs and a range of timing. Also the engine sounded louder. I wasn't happy the engine wasn't happy. I went back to points, all good again, amazingly good. The points, condenser and rotor came from the Distributor Doctor (as did the 3ohm Flamethrower, and the Ignitor - which is now relegated to the spare part bin). I also looked into 123 but wanted to keep the dizzy with mechanical tacho, so as recommended by DD I got the Ignitor. For other reasons I've had a lot of communications with Martin at 'Fred Millturn Parts', a specialist in TR6 Injection, he said don't use electronic ignition the TR6 PI doesn't like it. He's right. If you do 'go back' to points ensure you use a 3ohm coil. My setup is a Flamethrower 3ohm (does seem to be the best coil I've used). Points, Condenser and Cap from the Distributor Doctor. Magnecor 7mm electrosports HT leads (black, no bright colours!). Bosch W7DTC plugs. I've tried many combinations, this is the best. But did you get your distributor rebuilt by Martin? (Dizzy Doc) Stuart. Quote
Casar66 Posted July 25 Report Posted July 25 Quote but produced hesitant coughing/clapping acceleration at low revs That ist exactly the situation now. And it was much better WITH Ignitor 2. Quote
Jules TR6 Posted July 25 Author Report Posted July 25 10 hours ago, stuart said: But did you get your distributor rebuilt by Martin? (Dizzy Doc) Stuart. ...no, the main dizzy cam wasn't wobbly and everything clean (apart from the points) and no major loose play on the rotation, just the normal in spec spring-loaded slight rotational 1 degree spring-back. Got a felt pad for under the rotor to oil, for benefit of the weighed advance arms. A set of new points and condenser was all that was needed. Electronic ignition was a blind alley. Quote
Casar66 Posted July 26 Report Posted July 26 (edited) Let's suppose Martin is right and the TR6 does not like electronical ignition and my change of coil and leads would be fruitless. Then the Ignitor 2 ist the last part to change. And then? To buy a second Ignitor makes no sense. To buy another make either. I really should go back to points (what I do not really want, the quality becomes too bad in the meantime). Will Martin not like the lumination optronic too? Another alternative could be just a ignition conversion like the german Fessler or cheaper the Accuspark sx4000 https://accuspark.co.uk/products/sx4000-ignition-conversion The points are still there but no points that burn out due to poor quality, no cheap knockoff condenser that gives out prematurely. Maybe that could be answer? Edited July 26 by Casar66 Quote
RobH Posted July 26 Report Posted July 26 We seem to be getting into the realms of voodoo here. A car does not care where the spark comes from - just that it occurs at the right time and is hot enough to ignite the fuel. All the systems mentioned are basically Kettering types. The only difference is detail in how the current to the coil is being turned on and off. Quote
Jules TR6 Posted July 26 Author Report Posted July 26 (edited) 1 hour ago, Casar66 said: The points are still there but no points that burn out due to poor quality, no cheap knockoff condenser that gives out prematurely. The condensers from DD are tried and tested, and of solid dependable quality. I would not rule out trying points again. I met a friend of a friend a year ago at a rally, he has a E-type he purchased new back in the days, and knows it very well - what it was like to drive brand new. He’d tried electronic ignition and didn’t think the engine liked them at all, went back to points. I don’t see much reason in chasing a dream in keeping trying different EI solutions, the car always ran fine on points and as did 1,000’s of others for decades. I’d try and make the Ignitor work well first, if after all your efforts then try points, condenser and rotor from DD. You’ve now got non suppressed plugs in, gapped about 0.028” - 0.030”. Next use suppressed leads, something like Magecor. Try different timings, 11 degrees, 16 degrees, with the engine chugging at 800rpm. Could the weighted advancement arms inside the dizzy be not free moving? Do you oil the felt pad under the rotor? Edited July 26 by Jules TR6 Quote
RogerH Posted July 26 Report Posted July 26 Your Dizzy Doc capacitor looks like a can of beer. Roger Quote
Hamish Posted July 26 Report Posted July 26 If it’s of any use I have a sporting/race TR3a which I have used the points swap accuspark electronic module with great success. And when I upgraded the engine went to FIA compatible points distributor at the engine builder’s recommendation which my rolling road guy fine tuned the plates with welds and file. Goes great. and more recently I had to swap a luminition system from my 1937 Alvis as the VSCC don’t like electronic the distributor Dr built me a replacement distributor with points, condenser and his red rotor arm and it’s great. so they all can work for you. You just need to decide which way to jump. As in ordinary road driving it’s unlikely you’ll notice a difference in any well set up system. Quote
Casar66 Posted July 26 Report Posted July 26 Well, if I had real ignition problems with my cars or bikes, If TR, Alfa, Ford or Vespa and Ducati, it were always the points or condenser due their poor quality. So because of that I am very sceptical. Of cause there we're problems with the electronical ignition too, but never anything what what made me stop. Quote
Casar66 Posted July 26 Report Posted July 26 Yepp, I will do so If I finally decide to go back to points. Since Brexit ist is not that attractive to order in GB like it was before. Maybe I found similar parts in Europe. Quote
DRD Posted July 26 Report Posted July 26 On 7/23/2026 at 9:12 PM, Jules TR6 said: Just to report on what's working well... Put the NGK BP6ES in, gapped 0.030" which seems to have always been the optimum (the coil can more than enough cope), low rpm pick-up not exceptional but ok (as I've come to expect of a classic car), once above 2000rpm very responsive. On the whole better than the WR78 (though as we know I'm using somewhat suppressed (3kohm) HT cables, so suppressed plugs are out). Then went back to the Bosch W7DTC, so much better. I have no bias or allegiance, just reporting, the engine so likes these plugs. Even starting, only needs a few seconds of the fuel pump then starts first time. The Bosch W7DTC is unusual as seen at the top of this post, they extend further into the cylinder than any of the other plugs, whether this is good or bad or indifferent, I don't know, but maybe this and the more exposed spark of the tri-electrode arrangement seems to be what the engine is liking - in all its primitiveness of the injection squirt etc. Reading other reports of plugs on this and other forums, the NGK BP6ES is always mentioned, though the Bosch W7DTC does get a lot of positive feedback, rightly so I'd say. Jules, have you noticed any difference between BP6ET and W7DTC, they are both triple electrode plugs? Darren Quote
Schnippel Posted July 26 Report Posted July 26 Hello that an electronic ignition isn't suitable for the TR fuel-injected engine? I have to laugh! Then all the modifications I've made in recent years wouldn't run very well! And that would be completely unacceptable to me. If you install an electronic module, it's absolutely crucial to check the position of the distributor rotor relative to the spark plug wire contact in the distributor cap. The rotor's nose must be level with the spark plug wire contact. If, for example, it's almost past it, you'll get misfires at high RPMs and with the centrifugal advance at maximum. Conversely, you'll get misfires and rough running at idle and during partial load transitions, while everything will be perfect at high RPMs. The stator plate must be adjusted together with the entire distributor. It can be a bit fiddly. These are small issues with a big potential for frustration. Best regards, Ralf Quote
stuart Posted July 26 Report Posted July 26 37 minutes ago, Schnippel said: Hello that an electronic ignition isn't suitable for the TR fuel-injected engine? I have to laugh! Then all the modifications I've made in recent years wouldn't run very well! And that would be completely unacceptable to me. If you install an electronic module, it's absolutely crucial to check the position of the distributor rotor relative to the spark plug wire contact in the distributor cap. The rotor's nose must be level with the spark plug wire contact. If, for example, it's almost past it, you'll get misfires at high RPMs and with the centrifugal advance at maximum. Conversely, you'll get misfires and rough running at idle and during partial load transitions, while everything will be perfect at high RPMs. The stator plate must be adjusted together with the entire distributor. It can be a bit fiddly. These are small issues with a big potential for frustration. Best regards, Ralf Says he using a riveted rotor arm? Stuart Quote
Jules TR6 Posted July 26 Author Report Posted July 26 3 hours ago, DRD said: Jules, have you noticed any difference between BP6ET and W7DTC, they are both triple electrode plugs? Darren I did, BP6ET seemed to soot up fairly quickly. W7DTC stays cleaner. The thing is, I and probably everyone else are often making 'improvements', so while I make observations (and copious notes about those observations along the way), it's tricky to point any fingers at one item. The plugs are cheap, and easy to swap after having tried them for a 100 miles or so, everyone's 50-60 year old engine with mods will be different, different plugs etc may suit one engine more than another. My default is always to keep reverting to the default (points and BP6ES) if there's any issues I can't solve. Then make one change in a direction if desired / required. Quote
Jules TR6 Posted July 26 Author Report Posted July 26 (edited) 3 hours ago, Schnippel said: that an electronic ignition isn't suitable for the TR fuel-injected engine? I have to laugh! Then all the modifications I've made in recent years wouldn't run very well! I'm sure it would take many years to convert an old engine to a completely different brain. The PI runs overly rich at low rpm, in order that there's enough fuel to respond to any increase in air. The fuel mix is designed for acceleration, not coasting. The relationship of the physical points and the dizzy advance weights does seem well tuned, albeit primitively, to the PI fuel oddities on very sudden throttle opening or high rpm. The ignition timing shouldn't matter to this, but in a situation where there's an overabundance of fuel, then a sudden overabundance of air, cutting edge electronic ignition timing systems might be better suited to fuel air balances that are more modern and predictable. The Triumph Lucas PI is somewhat back to front, in modern engine design terms... for sure probably anything can be made to work with anything, though the method that was given (in the late 60's), and worked, there no reason why it still can't work along with the rest of the whole package, and work just as well, and more simply. I'm not contesting that your highly engineered German electronic ignition system works very well, though whether it might be recommended for someone having ignition trouble, maybe not. Probably in their case, and in most, find the source of the issue using the default systems and parts first. Edited July 26 by Jules TR6 Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.