Speedy Posted October 16 Report Posted October 16 As part of my restoration, I started the engine for the third time, this time to tune the Weber carburetors. After running for a short while, the oil pressure suddenly dropped to almost zero. I switched the engine off immediately and started troubleshooting. There are only a few possible culprits: the oil pump, the oil pump drive, the Purolator oil filter housing, or the oil pressure gauge. The oil pump was brand new and had been thoroughly checked before installation. But you never know, do you? So, I removed the distributor to gain access to the oil pump drive from above. Everything looked fine. Next, I drove the oil pump with a cordless drill, and sure enough, the oil pressure gauge showed a rise in pressure! I then removed the Purolator filter housing, but nothing obvious stood out. Still, the fault had to be somewhere in there. I later met up with an old hand from the TR community, someone who has been working on TRs day in, day out for over 50 years. He spotted the problem straight away! Over the decades, the seat for the oil pressure relief valve ball had worn down, allowing the ball to sit too deep. As a result, the spring effectively became too short, and the relief valve was opening far too early, causing the oil pressure to drop. My son Colin repaired the Purolator housing by machining the worn valve seat and turning a brass bush, which was then pressed into place. This restored the correct seating depth and gave the spring much more preload, allowing the relief valve to do its job properly again. This is what the ball valve seat looked like before the repair. It had worn down far too much, allowing the ball to sit way too deep. From the inside, you can clearly see how the material has been pushed in over the decades. After the repair, the ball sits much deeper in its seat. Here you can see the brass bush from the inside. My son Colin filmed the repair process. If you're interested in seeing how he fixed the Purolator oil filter housing, just click on the YouTube link below and check out the video! 🔧🚗 Quote
BlueTR3A-5EKT Posted October 16 Report Posted October 16 (edited) Interesting. I have not ever seen that problem manifest before. I think the ball valve that you have very nicely and expertly restored is the ’clogged filter’ oil bypass valve and I would not have expected it to have anything to do with running oil pressure, If the filter is blocked oil bypasses through that ball valve to continue oil flow to the engine oil gallery. Do you have an oil pressure warning light switch in the main oil gallery that is after the filter? Is that what alerted you to oil pressure drop? https://triumphspecialtuning.com/product/low-oil-pressure-warning-switch-kit-tr2-4a-and-morgan-4/ My first thought…..Was the inner rotor of the oil pump pinned to its drive shaft? A job I always check and implement on TR replacement oil pumps. The splined fit only method of attachment is known to come loose, stopping all oil delivery. The spindle still turns but the rotor, that does the pumping, does not. Edited October 16 by BlueTR3A-5EKT Quote
Trev Good Posted October 16 Report Posted October 16 (edited) Interesting, on reading the first part of your post, I thought 'aha, a bit of swarf has got under the pressure relief valve'. Glad you found the problem! Edited October 16 by Trev Good Quote
Speedy Posted October 16 Author Report Posted October 16 4 hours ago, BlueTR3A-5EKT said: Do you have an oil pressure warning light switch in the main oil gallery that is after the filter? Is that what alerted you to oil pressure drop? https://triumphspecialtuning.com/product/low-oil-pressure-warning-switch-kit-tr2-4a-and-morgan-4/ Yes, I still have the separate oil pressure warning light installed, along with the adapter from TR Enterprise. The warning light came on when the oil pressure started to drop. I’ll carry out a more thorough test over the weekend, weather permitting. So far, we’ve only started the engine briefly after the repair, and the oil pressure immediately went up to 70 psi. Quote
Z320 Posted October 16 Report Posted October 16 (edited) Hi Rainer, looking at the lenght of the spring IMO it should not matter, if the ball valve diggs in the seat. Anyway, I hope you found the problem. Ciao, Marco Edited October 16 by Z320 Quote
Trumpy3 Posted October 16 Report Posted October 16 I'm with Peter on this. The repair you done on the filter head should not affect the oil pressure. That ball is there to provide oil to the main gallery if the pressure drop across the filter becomes high enough to indicate the filter has become completely or partially blocked. In a perfect world, that bypass valve should never activate but in the real world it can under certain conditions. It does not affect the gallery oil pressure. It is possible that when removing and cleaning the filter head, you fixed the problem with out knowing. A faulty/stuck main oil pressure relief valve will affect the oil pressure but will not normally cause the indicated oil pressure to suddenly drop to zero. if the valve was stuck open it would be zero on start up. My first thought was the same as Peters, a failed oil pump. Still could be even though it is now showing oil pressure. Some times it will re- grip on shut down but will fail again. Another thought is the fitment of the distributor drive. It is possible to fit the drive gear and still allow the distributor/ oil pump drive gear to lift off of the oil pump drive flange. As you removed the drive to check the oil pump, refitting it correctly may have corrected the issue. If you do not find the cause of the pressure drop, I recommend you go back to that drive and check it. Brian Quote
BlueTR3A-5EKT Posted October 16 Report Posted October 16 (edited) 13 minutes ago, Trumpy3 said: I'm with Peter on this. The repair you done on the filter head should not affect the oil pressure. That ball is there to provide oil to the main gallery if the pressure drop across the filter becomes high enough to indicate the filter has become completely or partially blocked. In a perfect world, that bypass valve should never activate but in the real world it can under certain conditions. It does not affect the gallery oil pressure. It is possible that when removing and cleaning the filter head, you fixed the problem with out knowing. A faulty/stuck main oil pressure relief valve will affect the oil pressure but will not normally cause the indicated oil pressure to suddenly drop to zero. if the valve was stuck open it would be zero on start up. My first thought was the same as Peters, a failed oil pump. Still could be even though it is now showing oil pressure. Some times it will re- grip on shut down but will fail again. Another thought is the fitment of the distributor drive. It is possible to fit the drive gear and still allow the distributor/ oil pump drive gear to lift off of the oil pump drive flange. As you removed the drive to check the oil pump, refitting it correctly may have corrected the issue. If you do not find the cause of the pressure drop, I recommend you go back to that drive and check it. Brian My experience of a stuck open main oil pressure relief valve is the minimal oil pressure is still there at low rpm and rises with throttle opening. The only time I have experienced zero oil pressure with the engine running was when the incorrectly installed oil filter spewed all the oil out. Fitting error. The other checks would be the woodruff key on the oil pump drive shaft or tang on the shaft end that drives the pump. Those tangs are known to sheer off, but you would have found that on initial strip/investigation. Edited October 16 by BlueTR3A-5EKT Quote
Trumpy3 Posted October 17 Report Posted October 17 Yes, as I see it, only an oil pump or oil pump drive failure would give zero oil pressure. That assumes there is oil and the gauge is functioning correctly ??? Brian Quote
Speedy Posted October 18 Author Report Posted October 18 First of all, thanks for all of your thoughts on this. I wonder actually a little bit that there is no clear explanation on the function of the purolator with stats and facts. I am thinking of, what happens in the purolator with cold vicous oil? Does the bypass valve open then? At which internal pressure should it open? @Z320 Hi Marco, for me the actual length of the spring is important. The spring force increases proportional during compression. Prior to repairing the seat, it was pretty easy push the ball out of its seat while after the repair a higher force needs to be applied. Regarding a possible rotor slipping on the shaft, I have to admit that the pressure was never at zero. The pressure suddenly began to decrease while revving the engine at 2k with cold oil and within 10-15 seconds it dropped from 70psi to 5-10psi and did not recover from that. After idling it for 10 seconds at 5 psi (with low oil pressure warning active 🙃), panic started to set in and I shut the engine off. Yesterday we tested the repaired purolator housing more extensively. With the cold oil the pressure immediately rised ti 70 psi and never dropped a tad during the run. During testing we noticed a small oil incontinence around the purolator. It turned out to be the seal of the bolt for the spring of the oil blow off/bypass valve. We are having a little bit of trouble to seal this one but the actual question I am asking myself is: Why is obviously that much pressure in the chamber behind the ball valve while for my understanding it should be closed at that stage?? Any ideas or thoughts? 🙄 Thanks in advance Quote
Z320 Posted October 18 Report Posted October 18 Hi Rainer, I can’t look at parts at the moment. IMO the oil bypass valve (spring stronger losded) and oil reliev valve (spring adjustable) do the same. There is always a oil reflow behind the both steel balls via the relieve valve in the chamber I called „3“ in my club magazine article (if I remeber correctly). My purolator is constantly leaking a bit amd I can’t cure this, what ever I do. I guess this is a case for „Wasserglas“ this winter. Ciao, Marco Quote
stuart Posted October 18 Report Posted October 18 9 hours ago, Speedy said: First of all, thanks for all of your thoughts on this. I wonder actually a little bit that there is no clear explanation on the function of the purolator with stats and facts. I am thinking of, what happens in the purolator with cold vicous oil? Does the bypass valve open then? At which internal pressure should it open? @Z320 Hi Marco, for me the actual length of the spring is important. The spring force increases proportional during compression. Prior to repairing the seat, it was pretty easy push the ball out of its seat while after the repair a higher force needs to be applied. Regarding a possible rotor slipping on the shaft, I have to admit that the pressure was never at zero. The pressure suddenly began to decrease while revving the engine at 2k with cold oil and within 10-15 seconds it dropped from 70psi to 5-10psi and did not recover from that. After idling it for 10 seconds at 5 psi (with low oil pressure warning active 🙃), panic started to set in and I shut the engine off. Yesterday we tested the repaired purolator housing more extensively. With the cold oil the pressure immediately rised ti 70 psi and never dropped a tad during the run. During testing we noticed a small oil incontinence around the purolator. It turned out to be the seal of the bolt for the spring of the oil blow off/bypass valve. We are having a little bit of trouble to seal this one but the actual question I am asking myself is: Why is obviously that much pressure in the chamber behind the ball valve while for my understanding it should be closed at that stage?? Any ideas or thoughts? 🙄 Thanks in advance The pressure adjuster is sealed into the housing with lead linger which is similar to a soft solder and can be found amongst the fishing fraternity. Stuart Quote
Trumpy3 Posted October 18 Report Posted October 18 Rainer There is a lot of misunderstanding regarding the TR oil filter system. The early 4cylinder TR engine came with a bypass filter. This means that it only had one valve, the main oil pressure control valve. The one with its adjustment external on the filter head. With this set up, only the excess oil that is dumped by the PRV (pressure relief valve) flows through the filter back to the sump. In effect, no oil flows through the filter until the pressure goes above the PRV set value. So no oil flows through the filter until the pressure goes up to about 70PSI. Hence it is called a bypass filter. No oil filter flow at idle??? On later engines the oil filter head was modified so that the oil flowed from the oil pump to the filter via the PRV and on to the main oil gallery. The result is that all oil flows through the filter before the PRV. Excess oil flows from the PRV direct to the sump. Hence it is called a full flow filter. A much better system. As all the oil must flow through the filter a safety system must be incorporated to allow flow of oil when and if the restriction across the filter becomes so high it reduces the flow below a critical level. This devise is the bypass valve and is the one you worked on. You can identify the two different filter heads by the presents or absence of the bypass valve. You are correct in questioning when and if the bypass valve normally opens.Yes it does. If the filter gets too dirty because it was not changed regularly as required or its a low quality unit with poor dirt holding capacity. Also the viscosity affects the oils ability to flow through the filter medium. In cool to cold weather the oil pressure drop across the filter may cause the bypass valve to open. As the oil temperature increases,the pressure drop across the filter drops and the bypass valve will close.So in cold weather the bypass valve may open every time you start a cold engine meaning the oil will bypass the filter. This can be reduced by warming the engine before you raise the RPM, and hence oil flow, to the level it causes bypass. Hope this helps and not confuses. Brian Quote
Trumpy3 Posted October 19 Report Posted October 19 Rainer Just re read your last input. The pressure you read on the gauge is the main gallery oil pressure, the pressure after the filter housing and all its bits and pieces. If the pump is working as required, the only reason the pressure drops as you described, can be the PRV. this of course is providing there is no major loss after the main gallery which is most unlikely. I think you had a PRV sticking and the strip and clean fixed the issue. As mentioned by Stuart, the PRV adjusting screw is sealed with a lead wire. It is wrapped around the adjusting screw below the adjustment lock nut. The lock nut then compresses it into the threads and sealing it. The PRV assembly in sealed into the housing by a special stepped sealing washer. Brian Quote
Z320 Posted October 19 Report Posted October 19 With the pressure relieve valve the pressure can be adjusted below 70 PSI. This is why the bypass valve opens at a higher pressure? Quote
Speedy Posted October 19 Author Report Posted October 19 10 hours ago, Trumpy3 said: Rainer There is a lot of misunderstanding regarding the TR oil filter system. The early 4cylinder TR engine..... Hope this helps and not confuses. Brian Brian, thank you very much for the detailed explanation. A lot of things are much clearer to me now. Since the engine has just been rebuilt, I am still using a break-in oil, which is quite thick. With the cooler temperatures as well, this would mean that the bypass valve opens after starting the engine. To stop the oil leak at the bypass valve screw, I will add a small piece of lead wire under the screw head as an additional seal. The fluctuating oil pressure disappeared after I repaired the bypass valve seat. I had not removed the pressure relief valve again! My next question is: What exactly does this repair change? Now, considerably more force is required to open the bypass valve ball. This is actually how it should be on a new Purolator filter, isn't it? Unfortunately, there doesn't seem to be any information available on how much spring pressure there should be on the ball. 15 hours ago, stuart said: The pressure adjuster is sealed into the housing with lead linger which is similar to a soft solder and can be found amongst the fishing fraternity. Stuart The oil leak is coming from the screw on the bypass valve, not from the pressure relief valve. Quote
Trumpy3 Posted October 19 Report Posted October 19 Rainer The seal for the screw cap on the bypass valve should be a simple copper washer. The lead wire is only used on the PRV. Increasing the pressure to open the bypass valve will only reduce the effectiveness of the valve. Increasing the operating pressure on this valve is not a good idea. I have read somewhere that the operating pressure on the bypass valve is approx 8 - 10 PSI. In engines equipped with spin on oil filters, the bypass valve is built into the filter and not part of the engine itself. The TR was designed with a cartridge filter and as such needs one built in. The early bypass filter set up did not need one either as the filter was only a bypass one and excess restriction across it would not starve the engine of oil. This bypass valve is an easy way to tell the early (TR2) bypass filter head from a latter full flow filter head. Every one here with a bypass filter has either changed to a latter one or looking for one. Quote
Z320 Posted October 20 Report Posted October 20 Hi Brian, thank you for the sketch, showing me the bypass valve has no influence on the oil pressure on the gauge. Ciao, Marco Quote
Speedy Posted October 20 Author Report Posted October 20 Hi Brian, I used the lead wire as an additional seal on the bypass valve because there was still a small amount of oil leaking from it. As for the repair, I didn’t increase the spring preload any further. Instead, I adjusted it back to the original pressure. Since the ball had worn itself about 4 mm into the seat, the spring pressure was actually lower than it had been in the original condition. Thank you for your schematic illustration of the oil flow through the Purolator. However, I already have another question about it. I had also come across the figure of 8–10 psi operating pressure for the bypass valve before. But how is that supposed to work? Ideally, the oil pump delivers more than 70 psi. The oil flows through the filter, the pressure is regulated to 70 psi by the PRV, and then it goes to the oil pressure gauge and the main oil gallery. If the oil enters the filter at 70 psi and the bypass valve opens at just 10 psi, what pressure is actually left in the filter? I’m finding this really difficult to understand. I’m expecting another Purolator to be delivered today, and fortunately, I won’t have to remove the one from my TR. I’ll use the new one to trace the oil passages and try to work out how everything flows. Thanks again for your help! Quote
Lebro Posted October 20 Report Posted October 20 The bypass valve is not measuring the actual oil presssure it measurimg the difference in pressure across the filter which should be very little unless it gets blocked Bob Quote
Trumpy3 Posted October 20 Report Posted October 20 Correct Bob, I think that is where the confusion seems to be. look at the function of the by pass valve. A filter works by passing the product through a medium (sieve) to take out any unwanted matter. In the case of the oil filter, it is dirt and wear material. As the filter does its job, these particles are held in the filter and over time build up and increase the restriction across the medium. This restriction can build to the stage where the increase is so great that it starts to reduce the flow to an unwanted degree. Just think of the security gates at the airport. In a well maintained unit with quality products, this level of restriction should never happen but unfortunately not all owners do the right thing so the manufacturers build in a safety valve, just in case. The two pressures the bypass valve sees are the pressure on the oil pump side and the pressure on the filter outlet. The only thing that changes the relative difference in these two pressures is the restriction across the filter medium, not the pressure being applied to the filter from the pump. For a filter to work there will always be a restriction and in fact this gradual build up of dirt/wear metal gradually increases the efficiency of the filter making it harder for the medium being filtered to pass through. In my previous life, we saw oil filters get so efficient that they started to strip out some of the oil additives. Air filters are no different. In most industrial applications, air filters have a visual indicator to show the pressure drop across it and indicate when the filter needs cleaning/changing. Brian Quote
BlueTR3A-5EKT Posted October 21 Report Posted October 21 This Australian internet article mentions differential pressure across the filter when clogged. Just need to translate kilopascals to PSI. "Here's the scenario it's designed for: the filter media becomes so clogged with trapped particles that the pressure differential between the outside and inside of the media climbs too high. At a certain threshold , usually around 70–100 kilopascals of differential pressure , the bypass valve opens. This allows oil to flow directly from the inlet to the outlet, completely skipping the filter media." https://www.automotiveglobespecialist.com/post/how-does-oil-go-through-an-oil-filter Quote
Z320 Posted October 21 Report Posted October 21 Hi Brian, some jyears ago I had problems with a dropped oil pressure on the Autobahn too. Luckily at the end of the journey, 20 km countryroads from home. I assumed it was the relieve valve locked open, draining all the oil in the sump. But it could also has been the valve locked closed, this lets no oil to the bearings (and gauge). By dismantling and cleaning the valve I found nothing sepecial, so I fitted it back, adjusted it new and the issue never happened again. Strange….? Ciao, Marco Quote
Speedy Posted October 21 Author Report Posted October 21 Thank you all for trying to help me. I think I’ve understood everything now, although I believe the oil flow through the Purolator is a little different. Over the past few hours, I took the time to put together a schematic diagram showing the oil flow through the Purolator. Unlike Brian’s sketch, the oil pressure is measured upstream of the filter, and the PRV is also located upstream of the filter. The yellow cable indicates the oil flow path from the pump to the outside of the filter. The blue cable indicates the oil flow path from the inside of the filter to the main oil gallery. The white cable indicates the oil flow path from the bypass valve to the main oil gallery. The yellow line shows the oil flow from the pump. The oil flows toward the oil pressure gauge outlet (arrow) and the PRV. Yellow: From the oil pump Blue and white: To the main oil gallery Red: From the pressure relief valve to the sump I hope I’m not talking total nonsense here and got everything right 😂 What do you guys think? Quote
RogerH Posted October 21 Report Posted October 21 Hi Peter 10,000Pascals - 1.45 PSI. Pascals are tiny. Roger Quote
Lebro Posted October 21 Report Posted October 21 (edited) 36 minutes ago, Speedy said: Thank you all for trying to help me. I think I’ve understood everything now, although I believe the oil flow through the Purolator is a little different. Over the past few hours, I took the time to put together a schematic diagram showing the oil flow through the Purolator. Unlike Brian’s sketch, the oil pressure is measured upstream of the filter, and the PRV is also located upstream of the filter. The yellow cable indicates the oil flow path from the pump to the outside of the filter. The blue cable indicates the oil flow path from the inside of the filter to the main oil gallery. The white cable indicates the oil flow path from the bypass valve to the main oil gallery. The yellow line shows the oil flow from the pump. The oil flows toward the oil pressure gauge outlet (arrow) and the PRV. Yellow: From the oil pump Blue and white: To the main oil gallery Red: From the pressure relief valve to the sump I hope I’m not talking total nonsense here and got everything right 😂 What do you guys think? It does seem to be correct, & not as I had expected ! Bob Edited October 21 by Lebro Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.